are they really improving, or are they just winning? I will give you solddat, I do think he's on the improve, but no uncle mo.kimberley mine wrote:bdw0617 wrote: i have said it once, i will say it again, yoyu want to look for a horse that is improving and that is projecting towards the derby.
....
every race, the horse is getting better and better and better. he has not gone backwards yet. that, not stanima, not closing abitity, etc, is what you need to look for. there is no doubt in my mind now this horse will get 10F becuase baffert will have him ready.
BDW everything you say is true and it in no way is mutually exclusive with my points. Thing is, this horse is not the only one who has been steadily improving. Soldat and Uncle Mo both came out of their most recent races very well, and are head and shoulders above everybody else at this point. Stay Thirsty should move ahead from the Gotham. Premier Pegasus just ran a corker. The question isn't is he improving, which he obviously is, the question is, will this horse improve quickly enough to reach the same level on the first Saturday in May as his potential rivals? I'm not convinced.
Compare him with Soldat. TF has been in the lead in every race since his very first. Soldat proved that he can lay off and stalk the pace in Saratoga. He then showed he could rate, run wide, weave in to the rail, split horses to make a move, and finish strong in the BCJT. He didn't catch Pluck, but nobody was going to catch Pluck that day. In the allowance in the slop, he got eyeballed by another horse before taking off, and in the Fountain of Youth he got in the lead and stayed there. Though I still wouldn't bet him (because I think the temptation to get out front and use his natural speed would be too high), if I had to choose between the two I would take Soldat for those very reasons rather than TF.
no horse, in the country has gotten better from January to the end of march then the factor